| Platinum | Iron Bank Coffee Co. |
| Gold | Parlor Donuts |
| Silver | Midtown Coffee House |
| Bronze | Kung Fu Tea |
| Top Pick | Fountain City Coffee |
| Top Pick | My Boulange |
| Top Pick | Ruth Ann's Restaurant |
| Top Pick | The Brick and Mortar Cafe |
| Top Pick | The Mustard Seed At Sydney's |