| Platinum | The Black Cow |
| Gold | Country's Barbecue |
| Silver | Charred Oak |
| Bronze | The Food Mill |
| Top Pick | 11th and Bay Southern Table |
| Top Pick | Epic |
| Top Pick | Gabagool |
| Top Pick | Miles to Go Whitesville |
| Top Pick | The Animal Farm |
| Top Pick | Trevioli Italian Kitchen |
| Ruth Ann's Restaurant | |
| Thai House |